4.5 out of 5 stars

1,000+ Google reviews!

Castle & Key 2023 Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 750ml

Product information

$49.98
Product photo of Castle & Key 2023 Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 750ml
*Image for illustration, actual product may differ.

Product options

OFFER
$20 off shipping on orders $300+

In stock and ready to ship

100% satisfaction guarantee

10,000+ packages delivered safely

Product Description

Castle & Key restored the historic Old Taylor Distiller -- erected in 1887 -- with a new vision and promise. The awakening of this legendary bourbon icon enables us to create captivating spirits and endearing memories. We craft our spirits with carefully selected grains and a unique barrel regiment to thoughtfully produce distinct spirits to our exacting standards. Come raise a glass with us!

Product Specs

Alcohol by Volume50.5%
Country of OriginUnited States
RegionKentucky
UPC852657007419

Shipping

Ships to most states from California. Securely packaged and sealed, we have delivered over 10,000 packages safely to happy customers all around the USA.

Returns

It is against the law in the state of California to accept returns on alcohol except for defective or spoiled items. If there is an issue with the order, we will make it right 100% guaranteed.

Awards & Scores

Critic reviews and blind-tasting competition results for this bottle.

What critics and judges wrote

Wine Enthusiast · Kara Newman
Oak, cedar and toasted almond aromas lead the nose. The first sips open quite drying and tannic; adding water pulls in almond butter and crème brûlée tones, finishing long with clove and cinnamon heat.
Read the full review on wineenthusiast.com
Whisky Advocate · Julia Higgins · 2026
There’s some wood up front on the palate, but notes of single-origin coffee, açai, and cassis soon smooth it out. The finish turns darker, as dark-roast coffee, semi-sweet chocolate chips, Heath bar, and lemon peel take over.
Read the full review on whiskyadvocate.com
Distiller · Amanda Schuster
The palate is rich, oily, and viscous, with caramel and spice flavors up front. Fruity notes of apple and pear appear toward the back palate with more spicy heat ushering in a somewhat abrupt finish …
Read the full review on distiller.com
Beverage Testing Institute · August 2025
Amber color. Aromas of vanilla cream, dried apple, and tobacco with a medium body and a medium dried peach, toasted spice, and apple fritter finish. Smooth Bourbon that is remarkably approachable, fine for a big rock or Manhattan.
Read the full review on tastings.com

Competition medals

San Francisco World Spirits Competition
Silver 2022

1 medal from 1 competition, 2022.

Tasting Notes

Flavor profile

How strongly each flavor family shows up across 5 notes from 4 publications, weighted by source.

  • Herbal & greena trace of liliesA hint
  • Fruityfruity, dried pineapple, candied orange, açai, cassisLight
  • Sweetvanilla bean, Heath bar, vanilla cream, caramel, vanillaClear
  • Oak & maltsome wood up front, toasted breakfast cereal flakes, oak, cedar and toasted almond aromas lead the nose, drying and tannicClear
  • SmokeA hint
  • SpiceSpicy & Complex, toasted spice, clove, nutmeg, cinnamonLight

Flavor map

Castle & Key 2023 Small Batch against other bourbons we carry. Closer dots taste more alike.

← More delicateRicher →Less smokySmokier →Castle & Key2023 Small BatchPuncher'sChance 90ProofOld Fitzgerald Bottledin Bond 7 Year OldHirsch 'The Horizon'

Closest bourbons at a similar price: Puncher's Chance 90 Proof ($29.97), Old Fitzgerald Bottled in Bond 7 Year Old ($59.96), and Hirsch 'The Horizon' ($42.98).

Show the map as a list

Each whisky's place on the map, from 0 to 10.

WhiskyRichSmokyPrice
Castle & Key 2023 Small Batch (this bottle)4.40.1$49.98
Puncher's Chance 90 Proof4.50.0$29.97
Old Fitzgerald Bottled in Bond 7 Year Old4.60.0$59.96
Hirsch 'The Horizon'4.60.3$42.98
Booker's4.50.4$99.96
Blade and Bow4.00.0$59.98
Jefferson's Reserve Pritchard Hill Cabernet Cask Finished4.80.0$79.98
New Riff Distilling 8 Year Old4.00.0$99.96
Thomas S. Moore Cabernet Sauvignon Cask Finish4.80.0$74.98
Conecuh Ridge Distillery Clyde May's Special Reserve 6 Year Old4.80.4$64.98
Tuthilltown Spirits Hudson Whiskey NY 'Bright Lights, Big Bourbon'4.90.0$46.97
Redemption Wheated4.60.6$39.97
A. Smith Bowman Distillery 'Bowman Brothers' Pioneer Spirit Small Batch4.00.5$36.98
Angel's Envy Port Wine Barrel Finish4.80.5$34.97
1792 Sweet Wheat4.50.7$199.96
William Larue Weller4.50.7$1,699.96
Basil Hayden's 'Toast'3.80.3$79.96
Smooth Ambler 'Contradiction'3.80.3$45.98
McAfee's Benchmark Old No. 83.70.0$21.97
Redwood Empire Pipe Dream5.10.2$39.98
Woodford Reserve Master's Collection '1838 Style White Corn'3.70.0$499.96
Thomas S. Moore Chardonnay Cask Finish5.20.0$74.98
Chicken Cock5.00.7$59.97

Flavor scores are our estimates. A flavor scores higher when more critics mention it and when they describe it more strongly, so no single review sets the result. They are not a rating from any publication.

Loading...